Introduction
Historians studying ancient India rely on two broad categories of sources:
- Archaeological sources: Physical remains uncovered through explorations and excavations.
- Literary sources: Written texts from indigenous and foreign origins.
Archaeological Sources
Types of Archaeological Remains
- Mounds: Earth heaps from graves and settlements
- Artifacts: Ornaments, weapons, tools, and coins (numismatics)
- Inscriptions: Writings on stone, metal, or other durable materials (epigraphy)
- Organic remnants: Fossilized bones, plant material, fabric fragments
- Structures and monuments: Palaces, temples, tombs, bridges, sculptures
- Paintings: Cave paintings and wall murals
- Dwellings: Caves and rock shelters
Excavation Methods
- Horizontal Excavation: Covers large areas quickly and economically but faces challenges with inhabited sites.
- Vertical Excavation: Offers detailed stratigraphic data but is costly and time-consuming.
Strengths of Archaeological Sources
- Provide primary, contemporary evidence of past cultures.
- Reveal economic systems, social structure, technology, religious practices, and trade relationships.
- Crucial for periods lacking written records such as the Stone Age and the Harappan Civilization.
- Aid in verifying or challenging literary accounts.
Limitations
- Perishable materials often decay, leaving incomplete records.
- Artifacts may be disturbed, displaced, or manipulated by natural or human activities.
- Requires careful interpretation; biased or faulty methodologies can distort history.
- Archaeological evidence provides a monochromatic picture, lacking social norms, values, narratives, and language details.
Literary Sources
Categories
- Indigenous Literature: Includes religious (Vedic, Brahmanical, Buddhist, Jain texts) and secular (scientific, political, poetic) works.
- Foreign Accounts: Writings from Chinese, Arab, Greek, Roman travelers.
Indigenous Religious Texts
- Vedas: Comprise the earliest religious texts, including the Samhitas, Brahmanas, Aranyakas, and Upanishads.
- Sutra Literature: Ritual manuals and law codes (Dharma Shastras) detailing social and religious duties.
- Puranas: Mythological and genealogical texts blending history with devotion.
Secular Literature
- Scientific treatises, epics (Mahabharata and Ramayana), biographies, and political texts.
Importance and Issues
- Literary sources provide rich cultural, philosophical, and narrative context.
- Subject to interpolations and biases, requiring corroboration with archaeological evidence.
Specialized Archaeological Studies
Numismatics (Study of Coins)
- Reveals technological advancements, economic conditions, religious practices, and political chronology.
- Transition from irregular punch-marked coins to standardized coins with royal images and inscriptions started with Indo-Greeks.
Epigraphy (Study of Inscriptions)
- Inscriptions serve as reliable records of royal decrees, territorial extent, administrative structure, social customs, and foreign relations.
- Examples include Ashoka’s edicts and land grants from Gupta period.
- Less prone to manipulation than literary texts.
Conclusion
Effective reconstruction of ancient Indian history depends on integrating archaeological and literary sources.
- Archaeology offers tangible, primary evidence essential for periods lacking texts.
- Literary sources enrich understanding of beliefs, social norms, and narratives.
- Both types require careful interpretation and cross-verification to overcome inherent limitations.
By combining these diverse sources, historians can create a more comprehensive and nuanced picture of India’s ancient past. For further context, readers may explore the Comprehensive Overview of Ancient Indian History: From Prehistoric to Gupta Empire, which provides an extensive timeline that complements the archaeological and literary insights discussed here. Additionally, understanding more about the Early Vedic Age: An Overview of Aryan Migration and Civilization can illuminate the cultural background encapsulated in many literary sources. For deeper insights into archaeological techniques and challenges, the Comprehensive Guide to Prehistoric Archaeology and Dating Methods offers valuable supplementary information.
all right welcome now as we had discussed yesterday the first topic inent to cover is the
sources of ancient Indian Now sources that historians use to uncover the past may be divided
broadly into two categories one of them is archaeological
sources which represent the physical remains of the past and the other are the literary
sources which are the written texts left by the previous aric we can
include those physical remains which were created by previous cultures and civilizations they are found through
Explorations and expirations in the form of archaological Mounds which may consist of buried
structures HS of artifacts such as poy coins ornaments
weapons agricultural implements other tools Etc or maybe even some
Graves containing grave Goods okay so Mounds these are heaps of Earth which have been left behind
bys graes and gra GRS Etc then we have a variety of artifacts such as ornaments
weapons and tools that we can find then apart from this orical
evidence stud coins study of coins is known
as M matics inscriptions study of inscriptions is
known as igraphy
then what other kind of archaological material is relevant to uncover the past bones of animals and humans right so
fossilized bones may be important then decayed vegetative material right
such as decayed plants or grein or seeds Etc so fossilized creative material
important fabric very good fragments of fabric or clothing as a whole that may
be left behind what else built structures such as
monuments like ports palaces temples MOS tombs madrasas other structures pleasure Resorts Bridges ramp Parts Etc or Co
sculpture in the form of Idols or non idolic iconic sculpture what
else paintings done especially on Monument walls or the walls of caves Rock paintings Etc
what else the natural dwellings that prehistoric people used to dwell in such
as rock shelters or caves right archeological sources
archeological sources discover to Explorations or excavations what do they represent they
represent the physical remains of the past and they are a very important source of reconstructing history
literary sources on the other hand in the context of India may be broadly divided into two
groups indigenous sources and foreign sources or the accounts left
behind by Foreign visitors or foreign Travelers right foreign sources
categories sources could be divided foreign literature left behind by Chinese Travelers foreign literature
left behind by Arab Travelers and foreign literature left behind
by Breo Roman Travelers
right indigenous literature may be subcategorized into
secular and religious literature religious literature in
Ancient India primarily associated with which three important faiths
Hinduism Aran and brahmanical literature Buddhism and
jism secular literature scientific literature
example brah or the samita Etc all these are scientific
literatures then works of your literature such as various
plays ramas epics
poems Etc then literature of a chronical variety that
is the accounts of the Deeds of various Kings and other important personalities biographies of non-religious
personalities such as harita or viand charita oruo Etc so biographies
then works on other non-scientific secular subjects such as law or poity or Administration such as the AR shastra or
Niti shastra so political treatises
and works which deal with the expression of art the method of of production of art the way in which athetic
sensibilities should be shaped Etc right work such as the Kamas Sutra or the N shastra
right cultural Works Etc okay so this is a superficial survey of
the different kinds of sources that are avail aailable to recreate Indian historians rely primarily on
these two types of sources to learn about Indian past
now historical sources may also be divided into two other categories primary
sources and the other is known as secondary sources what are primary
sources those archaological and literary Works which belong to the same period that the historians are studying for
example the edicts of Ashoka they belong to the period of Ashoka and were directly associated with it another
example literary example yes har charita right written by
banabhatta banabhatta was a contemporary of harsharan and had a regular audience with he was an eyewitness to the various
developments that took place during haran's re right and this kind of source is known as a primary source
sources which are contemporary to the period of
study in a sense they represent a firsthand account of the development
as they were happening okay secondary
sources sources sources that are
derived from primary sources in most
cases they are non-contemporary to
the period of study for example B sorry bery wrote a work known
as the fahi in which he has written about the achievements and administrative polic policies of not
only fosa tlak but many other great Sultans of Delhi including balban ilesha Alin Ki and Muhammad bin tlak also so
while he was a contemp ofl and was writing in the Reign
ofak his accounts with regards toos policies and achievements they were contemp they were eyewitness but can see
be said for his accounts of the dees of PR Sultans know between ilish and balban there was almost a 100 Year Gap right
they were not contemporary at all and thus uh and even if it is
contemporary not all contemporary accounts can qualify as primary sources some are secondary sources for
example example isami wrote about mamad isami was a major uh follow of the
bahman sulate that had been created by successfully rebelling against okay now he was criticizing the
policies of Muhammad bin tlak but did he have eyewitness account firsthand experience of
Muhammad no okay so that kind of source is also a secondary source so it is derived from other
Prime so it is not and eyewitness account or
firsthand account now of law
evidence first hand account second hand account fir hand account right so eyewitness account is considered to be
more reliable with accurate detail that source is considered to be more so among
these sources primary and secondary sources primary sources are considered to be
more reliable okay this is another basis on which the historical sour basis primary or
secondary Aral and literary sources clear now we are going to take a look add these archaological and
literary sources One By One The Heading archaeological sources these represent these
represented the physical Remains the physical remains of the
past remains of the past stop they may consist
of they may consist of the following types of
sources consist of the following types of sources one by one you can write down
Mounds ornaments weapons and tools coins inscriptions
human and animal remains human and animal remains plant material plant
material grains and seeds
seeds next fragment of Fabrics or clothing monuments and
settlements monuments and settlements sculpture sculpture
cave and wall paintings lastly caves and rock shelters caves and rock
shelters Etc okay next Point essentially essentially archaeological remains
are the accumulated are the accumulated cultural
material left behind by
Pon culture cultures by byon cultures that are Unearthed that are Unearthed to Explorations and
excavations through Explorations and excavations okay next
Point archaeology archaeology relies
primarily primarily on two types of
excavations two types of excavations a horizontal excavation or a vertical excavation down one and two
horizontal excavation and vertical excav both of them have their advantages and weaknesses what is the advantages associ
what are the advantages associated with horizontal excavation large area can be covered at
a or with relative ease right and secondly it is much easier and cheaper to do than vertical exp right like
weakness that land which hisian or archeologist try to excavate it is not always vacant
land it is uh often settled land the present day communities are occupying this those communities would have to be
displaced or only for the purpose of Archaeology is it moral or even fible to displace large numbers of peoples not
all social invol horizontal exploration excavation
vertical excavation strength that a properly vertically
excavated site can give a complete blueprint of the pattern of settlement in that particular period it can give a
complete of the evolution of human life in that particular region right so exhaustive and detail
stud Associated expensive it is a very very tedious process or delicate work
Associated large number of experts with aties are required and it is a very timeing process okay these are the
uh strengths and weaknesses of both types of excavations okay next Point Le both of these both of
these have their own strengths and weaknesses have their own strengths and
weaknesses the point while horizontal excavation while horizontal excavation is the first
step is the first step towards a major archaeological
Discovery your archical discovery and may be undertaken may be
undertaken with relative ease relative e the biggest
problem is that the sites under investigation sites under
investigation are often inhabited which creates a further which
creates a hurdle creates a hurdle towards further excavation inhabited inhabited
which creates a hurdle towards further excavation except point on the one hand one hand
vertical excavations can help create an exhaustive
picture and help create an exhaust the picture of
the evolution of human life in a particular area it is a time
taking the time taking expensive and delicate process
is a time taking expensive and delicate process so sometimes it may take several decades to fully develop a uh single
site right it consumes a lot of the expert attention that is available to us so it
is not always possible to simultaneously excavate all the sides of uh importance or interest
forve trade next main point despite these weaknesses despite
these weaknesses Archaeology is considered essential
considered essential for recreating the past for recreating the
past First St why because it has a certain specific strengths which other sources lack this is due to the
following strengths this is due to the following strengths which category of sources do you think
most of them fall under primary or secondary sources primary sources reliable primary sources because they
are contemporary and uh they are directly associated with the area of Interest write down archeological
remains sub points number one archeological remains primarily fall under the
category primarily fall under the category of primary sources which are
contemporary to the period of study and directly associated with its historical context
does does they are considered to be more important sorry they are considered to
be more reliable they are considered to be more reliable or
strength that while are iology remains silent on several important aspects of the past such as the social norms values
philosophy the narratives and stories or myths that drove those previous cultures they are quite vocal about certain other
aspects such as coins inscriptions scientific development
we can know about the kinds of animals that were domesticated CRS that were being grown
which can also give us insights about the that was dominant during that period we can know about their fashion we can
know about their fashion technology also we can know about uh things such as planning construction material and
quality from their graves and Grave goods from cultures their Idols Etc we can know about their religious beliefs
their beliefs in context as life after death depending on the sizes of the houses or the quality of grave Goods the
quantity of grave Goods you can also know about social inequalities present in the society from the number of coins
from the quality of coins purity of coins you can know about the volume of trade the volume of uh
commercialization and the general level of prosperity that was present in society from uh the placement of
inscriptions we can know about the territorial extent of various rulers right
Empire we can also know about foreign contacts from the presence of coins from the presence of seals and sealings we
can know about the distribution of Education from the distribution of script whether it was widely in
circulation or was it limited to some Elite context so this kind of information also
you can so write down archaeology our next Point number two
archaeology can also shed light upon various aspects such
as economy aspects such as economy social structures and
relations social structures and relations agriculture
climate religion passion settlement pattern
change production and sorry inequality Etc inequality
Etc okay so this is another strength of archaeology thir strength
that are literary sources available for All Phases of Indian
history no they are available only for the historical phase and even in the historical phase there are several gaps
that remain both the as well as foreign Source periods around people we not have any literary information so how to to
fill those gaps by relying upon archaeology okay write down
Archaeology archology is critical for studying those
periods for which literature remains silent literature remains
silent can you give some examples the entire Stone Age prehistory okay and even India's protohistoric that
is the haran civilization scpt exist but does that tell us anything directly about how the
haran people thought what they believed Etc n because it has not been deciphered so
its significance remain conf remains confined to theology but it exist only in the form
of an archaological source for us in the haran context and nothing more right so that is one othery
next number four now even for historical phases literary evidence
available can the veracity of the literary evidence be verified by archaological sources in any manner
that means that this literary source is reliable that rces the veracity of these
literary sourer information write down
archaeology archaeology also plays a very important role plays a very important
role in verifying in verifying or
discrediting or discrediting literary sources Lally
okay next main point however however are chological
sources also suffer from certain limitations from
certains from certain limitations limitations aric perishable material do human beings
work only with sorry non peral material do human beings work only with stone no they also work with wood they
also work with leather they also work with fabric they also work with with mud and straw structures
tools right but the nature of this material is perishable in nature with time it gets deay it degenerates and
then finally it disappears so the picture that is Left Behind is is it a complete picture or is it a distorted
picture is a distorted B don't an inherent weakness of archaeology an inherent weakness of
Archaeology is that it relies almost exclusively on non perishable
materials all almost exclusively on non- perishable remains on non- perishable
remains to recreate the past to recreate the past this
presents this presents a distorted picture this presents a distorted
picture because human beings rely upon
both non- perishable and perishable materials to build their
lives and perishable materials and who build their
lives perishable material we get an income complete and distorted next
shortcoming even the per sorry even the non- perishable remains that we get such as coins inscriptions or fossilized
bones or fossilized veins or monuments or Fabric or Ms
artifacts is there any certainty that we find them exactly in the state that they were left behind no chances are that
they have been Disturbed and manipulated over time natural Calamity flood so many of
these are washed away or destroyed uh some earthquake comes many monuments fall down some Invasion takes place many
of these are deliberately destroyed some coins are discovered somebody uses them for his own use right gold coins and
silver coins melt them down and use it for your own these kinds of things also happen sh natural and manmade factors
say these historical remains are manipulated over time they are dispersed and displaced does the picture that we
get through them is not always accurate example history record Asoka had erected several pillars
across the length and Bre of his Empire primarily in North IND in Western and another at toar
dayana why because phosa saw them found them and had them dragged to fosa install them over there they have been
moved from their original Lo hisi so what may have emerged as a
counter historical narrative that the region of Delhi was a very important part of the Moran Empire
it was one of the regional capitals of ashuka important political Center economic Center this may have been the
Imp that may have been right so it is very easy to distort the image of the past through the
manipulation of archeological okay write down archaological
remains H next Point archaeological remains are often
Disturbed or displaced by natural or human
forces does leaving behind does leaving behind a distorted
picture leaving behind a distorted picture okay next shot coming number
three now is the simple discovery of these archaeological remains of the
past uh sufficient to recreate history no it has to be interpreted also interpret the historians different
Scholars right is there any guarantee that there is going to
beated knowy or maybe they are suffering from some bias or there may be certain
truisms in the field which later on may be revealed to be untr dogas later on be challenged and shattered right but
interpretations they are going to result in the creation of the historical narrative associated with that AR
ological source and because of these bias and laws and faults in methodology picture that ised that is corrupted
right down archaeological sources must be
interpreted by historians by historians to understand the their relevance understand their
relevance to understand their relevance however
misinterpretations due to personal bias misinterpretations due to personal bias
or faulty methodology or faulty methodology
May corrupt the historical narrative they corrupt the historical narrative example
the historical narrative they corrupt the historical narrative any example you can
give discover one of the seals that was discovered consisted or carried the image of a human being with an elaborate
headgear in a yogic position who are surrounded by animals on all s John
Marsh Proto right so John Marshall who was aware about the Hindu god Shiva had ascribed the status of Shiva to this
figure found on the har history later analysis that Shiva was a god which
appeared for the first time during the later secondly and
Arians they were different sets of so there was very little chance of them sharing the same philosophical base
right so this kind of interpretation is what we are saying is a faulty interpretation misin
example theories one of the earliest theories that was put forward was the Aran
Invasion okay proant of this theory was another famous Colonial
historian e and evidence he said
that excavations at moan jaro have revealed the remains of 26 skeletons and common feature in all
these skeletons is that their bodies were discarded they were not properly buried
and all of them carry wound marks
okay evid inference martim
weer that moar was probably the site of some major battle or Invasion where the helpless people of madaro were
mercilessly slaughtered by certain groups of Outsiders and who were these Outsiders Arians okay however later
research perod to belong some of these skeletons died 300 years before the other skeletons
so secondly it was also found that in almost all these skeletons the cause of death was not these wounds that had been
inflicted by some weapons they died later after these wounds had already healed could the Arians be blamed for
the of these 26 people and thus is the RN Invasion Theory now considered to be as strong as in the times of Mortimer
wheeler so Aran Invasion theory is a perfect example of a of the misinterpretation of archaeological
sources a shortcoming to or shortcoming that you may be aware of archaeological sources
Now archeological sources information but they remain silent on certain important things such
as the myths of the cultures that created these artifacts the narratives and stories their Legends their value
systems the laws that they govern themselves by right these kinds of things it is not very easy to glean from
these archeological sources and need not only the skeletal or physical picture of the past but also the human
element human elementy in fact we don't even know what the people who left Behind These cultur
sound like what was their intonation what was the way in which freed with which they
spoke language what are the derivatives or the sucesses of those
languages right and do the picture left behind by archeological sources full color black and white picture black and
white picture monochromatic pict viid color write down the picture next point the pictures
the picture created by archaeological source is is
often monochromatic is often by archaeological sources is often
monochromatic as compared to literary sources as compared to literary sources
are monochromatic as compared to literary sources
which present a much more lively image of the
past of the past okay now a general discussion about the
strength and weakness of archaological sources take down a question
underscore the importance of archaological sources
highlight their strengths and weaknesses 200 words 15 months take down another
question how does the study of
coins help us recreate ancient Indian history 100 words marks another question
shed light on the importance of
epigraphy in recreating history 100 words 15
mons I think first question you should be able to answer by this point of time we have already discussed the relative
strength and of the archeological sources and using this you can expore the importance of
aric archeological information that is what have to
Showcase you will have to use certain relevant examples I know
that but with the pass of as we go from history to Proto history to the historical phase you will get newer and
newer examples most relevant Maxim second question how does the study
of coins help us recreate ancient Indian history what is the study of coins known as numis mats
right the earliest coins to be issued in India coins punch mark
when were coins issued in India for the first time these punch Mark coins they were first issued during the
age of budha during the Maha Jan and they continued to be issued till the Moran
per okay that is from the 6th Century BC to the third century
BC what kind of metals were they made from Silver tin
and 14 14 is a greenish Brown alloy of lead and Tin
okay were they standardized coins having a standard weight or regular size or were they
Irregulars irregular points did they have the names of the Kings during whose Reign they were
issued Kings Canam 10 did they carry the dates of their issue they
had no images of Kings or
gods they had no dates and
also no inscriptions or Legends invol the
okay what did they have th marks punched upon them
hammer and punch them upon these coins images such as trees or the sun or moon or stars or peacocks or other birds and
animals Etc or geometric figures were punched upon them so punched images of
animals Birds stars and geometrical
figures another celestial bodies Etc they were found okay so punch
coin do we get any direct information about their religion or political history Dyas
records names of Kings Etc dates but we do get some very important useful information such
as so silver tin and protein metery they were aware of they were aw of the technology of mixing different Mater
Metals in uh fixed uh proportions to obtain Alloys we also know that uh which animals or
Birds these animals and birds can exist only in certain climates climatic information for example then the areas
from where these points have been found they represent the territorial domain of a particular region King issue coin
coin Merchant guilds we also come to know about the importance of merchant guilds in the society and since guilds
were important it also tells you about the importance of trade in the society growing trade this also tells you about
the economic transformation in the society from agrarian society to a secondary societ secondary economy the
economy was transforming the importance of CR production trade Commerce long distance trade short distance trade that
was all growing depending on the purity of coins and number of coins in circulation we can also get some
information with regards to the level of pro prosperity in the society the kind of economic transactions that were
taking place the level of monetization of the society Etc major change in Indian coinage took
place during the postm postm period May four different ruling dynasties from foreign land
established their empires in different parts of India usually North and Northwest confined right the first of
them were the Indo Greeks
and the indog Greeks were considered to be the pioneers of regular coin so they introduced
regular coins as opposed to The Irregular nature of the punch Mark a standard size a
standard shape a standard weight coins they were also the first to introduce B
coins they were also the first to introduce coins with
names and images of Kings they were also the first to
introduce coins with images and legends of different
gods and God it say right so now they became even more
useful as sources of History what kind of information can be glean from these regular Greek coins chronology establish
dtic history establish we also get firsthand evidence of religion and religious beliefs we
also get an idea of the artistic sensibility of the people who are making these coins because these coins were
issued by the Kings themselves we also learn about the shifting power dynamics when it comes to economic
manipulation merch Now power to regulate the economy is being assumed by the Kings themselves
the Kings have started playing a more important role in in regulating the economy right this new kind of
information also we can glean from these points and from the indog Greek period onwards Indian coinage continue to
evolve and over time several new feature to her period region or Dynasty coct which give us unique information
about those periods and help us distinguish the cultural context of those periods and regions from other
contemporary as well as non-contemporary periods and okay now but if you have to attempt this
answer how do coins help or how does the study of coins help us recate ancient Indian
history information so in introduction me you have to write within 20 to 30
words study of coins is known as
humatics what up it is an essential tool
for historical analysis since it sheds
light it sheds light on the following dimensions of this
okay so in these 20 to 30 words you have first given the context within which you will be writing your answer and you have
also highlighted the importance of points and the numatics for the recreation of History we have also
connected it with this connecting line to the next this is going to be your main
body as many dimensions as we can introduce that should be our objective to maximize the dimensional richness of
our points importance hisorical analysis coins tell us
about material advancement that is the level of Science and
technology we get information about the command of the people issuing these coins writing these
coins over metery which requires a number of
chemical processes and it also requires this melting of metallic or the melting of the uh metals
and the uh you can say shaping of the points finally right for sustained perod of time
so K making pyot technique
and fuel technology for example wood furnace
sufficient coal would have to be used or charcoal would have to be manufactured the kils would have to be designed in
specific manners AOW would have to be used right so
pumping mechanism would have to be made then very temperatures so this kind of material advancement was necessary for
making coins and the Very presence of coins tell us that this level of material advancement of Scientific
Technology had been attained had been achieved di what
else regular or dated coin you get dates and references the names of kings and dynasties that they
belong so it is very important for establishing chronology right dimensions at least for three or
four dimensions example for example you can write almost the entire chronology
of indog Greek Kings has been recreated on the basis of coinage
alone literary not have been able to know about all theod of their ra which king succeeded
whom right d right that we would have never known about right similarly coins are
also a very good source of learning about religion
you because because coins often carry the images of gods and goddesses they also carry Legends HS mantras Etc
associated with different gods and goddesses that can they can also shed light on uh the regional spread of
different religions similarly
coin we can also learn about the level of
trade right if large number of points of high domination high value are in circulation that means long distance
trade is flourishing L most of the coins small denomination low denomination daily
transactions coins use if there is a good balance what does it mean that both foreign as well as domestic
trade is flourishing in nature right coins can also shed light upon the level
of prosperity in a particular time period L economic conditions stable and if the
is if theall purity of precious metal coins is high that means Prosperity was high and there was economic stability
but when impurities are higher it means that Prosperity is declining or there are some economic
problems that are present then coins can also shed light on
territorial extent means that wherever these coins are found in
large numbers with great regularity these were the areas controlled by the people who used
to issue the inst then foreign
conts for example during the postmodern period a large number of Roman coins were found
in different parts of India that means that direct trade was taking place between India and the Roman
Empire we also learn about art Aesthetics and
sensibilities the way in which different Kings and gods are depicted in coins of different periods that is not constant
what change so indog Greek Kings completely different this also tells us not only
about the changing sensibilities of art but also about how the Kings or the ruling class of this wanted to
projects for example as a living incarnation of God himself as Vishnu right
who is the myological consort of Vish lakmi right Greek Kings on the other
hand what have they tried to do they have while they have tried to portray themselves as super human beings
L divinity claim so they have always presented themselves in profile
for and they always wearing a it is clear that they are Kings but element of divinity so the sensibilities of art as
well as Royal ideologies can be reflected in these points clear so this is the way in which coins
can help us in recreating conclusion diens 1 2 3 4 five six seven
right eight that is more than conclusion what was the
question how does the study of coins help usate children in history how can you conclude this
answer the study of history
would does be
incomplete without coins okay full stop
coins give us essential information which if
absent would permanently that is it you have to underline the
importance of coins in recreating next question on the importance of epigraphy
in recreating once again introduction me first of all you'll have to explain
what is epigraphy epigraphy it refers to the
study of inscriptions further you will continue inscriptions are considered to be
among the most most valuable form
of archaeological sources due to their following strengths their following
strengths is strength this is going to be the main body what are the strengths of
inscriptions they shed light on the level of material advantage inscriptions you need specific tools it
is also found that inscriptions were not always Ed on the stones pillars and monuments at the place where those ston
pillars and monuments are presently situated in fact those uh pillars were prepared in a particular place they had
to be transported over long dist communication infastructure teolog support right they also tell us
about settlement patterns and trade
routs inscriptions these were messages that had been inscribed upon stone or walls of
monuments or pillars Etc by different people such as Kings or prominent mobiles or Merchants Etc right now what
do you think was the purpose of these inscriptions to give a message to the ordinary people and and mageary
people important cities and towns or along important trade routs cities towns trade routs but okay
so the location of these inscriptions can also help us recreate the geographical location of important
cities towns and the trade routs next these inscriptions also shed light on
the teritorial extent of the empires for example
Ashoka who left behind a large number of inscriptions inscriptions
now we get his inscriptions from uh North Pakistan also we get his
inscriptions from utarak also get his inscriptions from the India Nepal border biar the whole of Bangladesh get his
inscriptions from orisha also Andra Pradesh also K also and Gujarat
also that all mades so all these places were part of ashoka's this entire
Zone was under the influence of the a okay next
now who these inscriptions we can also get information about cultural uh contacts between different groups of
people right we can know about historical migrations
right there is a site in Turkey known as Bas koi we have an inscription over here
that carries the text of a treaty between two tribes that had been fighting each other for a very long time
right these were the hitani andani tries significant Discovery thatat both the leaders of both these
tribes vowed or took Oaths in the name of certain gods or concept Gods mentioned in
Indra vun Ashwini twins Etc right Gods Gods weic Gods these were the gods that
Arians used to worship that means that Bas inscription which is dated to around 2000 BC
belongs to the Aran and or India migrate right this tells us
about the origin of that it was outside India then we can also get information about
the language and script used by people in different parts
of the country during different time periods for example at gandahar
the languages used were Greek and aramic region Greek influence or middle
eastern influence right the scripts were also Greek and aramic at shahabas
gari and man the language was prit but the script
was a or rest of India May the language was procrit but the script
was okay this it tells us about the distribution of various linguistic and strural communities in the mod Empire
similar analysis can be made for other time periods also for example suum period and po period
deep incription Tamil inscriptions Tamil inscription as in other parts of India prit and Sanskrit inscription will find
more okay so language and script then foreign contacts or foreign
relations yes for example
aokas 13th major Rock edict consists of the list of those countries where he had sent his dhad
dutas that is those Ambassador which he had sent specifically to spread dhama countries rers names mentioned that
means formal contacts existed between themma further we find a list of five Greek
kingdoms along with the names of their kings with whom Ashoka had exchanged Raj dutas or ambassadors embassies in
countries asok establish right this tells us about the existence of foreign contact diplomatic
as well as cultural contacts what other kind of information does do inscriptions
provide they provide us dynastic knowledge
and political information relevant to important Kings for example
the r prasti of samudra gupt incription is
aeric inscription meaning it is written in the form of ay prash form that is why prasti here what is primarily
listed the military achievements of similarly
the iole inscription this is another ulistic Tanger inscription belonging to pulin thei
written by Ravi kti it also encapsulates the military exploits of P the second including his victory over arhan so
important battles political developments details then these inscriptions also shed light
on social Customs religious institutions and
practices etc for example Iran inscription belonging to the year 510
CE for the first time gives the evidence of the practice of Sati okay
similarly aokas second major Rock edict talks about the presence
of slavery in the mod Empire Ashoka instructs his people that slaves should be treated kindly with love and
affection they should not be killed unnecessary these kinds of things we come to
about then many of these descriptions are also in the form of Charters public
Charters the names of officials their titles and their duties Etc they are mentioned
and recreating the structure of AD and by learning these details about the administrative structure we can also
learn about the responsibilities of the state and knowing this we can go about the nature of the political system the
amount of power that was exercised by the king and the way in which power was power was shared between the center and
the peripheral regions as well as the top levels of administration how it was delegated to the levels below right
administrative structure and nature of quality
then from the Gupta period onwards we start finding new types of inscriptions inscriptions inscriptions
recording BRS of land initially to Priestly class and to religious s and later to officials especially military
officials so land grants the rise of
plalism Etc this is all also reflected in the inscriptional records right and land grants sat
not only ownership of the land or the right to collect revenue from the land was transferred by the Kings to the
donies to the granes but also certain other powers it also imposed certain liabilities and duties upon the people
who were inhabiting these lands right so it also tells us about the evolution of the society the way in which labor was
distributed the way in which the state as well as its subsidiaries that is the beasts and the feudal Lords exercise
control over the general population The Peasants the producing class right so agrarian
structure and social relations also
reflected through these inscriptions right then apart from this
information inscriptions through we also find certain inscriptions which are apolitical in
nature political inscriptions they are in cribed either by the Kings or their subordinates governor regional
administrator and some a political inscriptions a political inscriptions they were V
inscriptions also known as donative inscriptions the deed of a donation made by an
individual or group of individual towards a particular resident primarily a priest or a group of priest or a
religious institutions Temple or a mut or a Buddhist Monastery or the Buddhist s right so
and such reles similar kind of inscriptions were
also made recording donations made by individuals or groups towards certain
recipients right ancient period private individuals
Merchants right so the importance of merchant
guilds is also reflected from these donative in not only importance of merchant guilds but specifically in
different regions different kinds of GS us to operate so distribution
of merchant me reflect okay so this is the importance
of inscriptions for recreating the ancient past conclusion
does our understanding of the past would remain incom
complete without as compared to literary sources they considered to be far more reli sources
or inscriptions but inscriptions
sour virus if tree leaves ET sub perishable material inscriptions Stones walls copper
plates what would be easier it is easier to manipulate literary sources far more difficult to
manipulate inscriptional sources right therefore inscriptional sources are relatively free from redactions or
interpolations examp prasti is actually written on one of the pillars left behind by Ashoka at
inscriptions one inscription obviously belongs to Ashoka the other belongs to samudra gupt
samt later inscription belongs to had them inscribed on top of the inscription left behind
by Original Part original inscription this has been embossed on top of the original incription of right so this is
another strength of the inscriptions over the literary Source right down they are far more
reliable than literary sour es and literary sources yes you are right uh noras it
also helps to corroborate information provided by the other sources the coins or the archaeological sources right so
far more reliable than the literary sources since they are since they are free from
reductions and interpolations reductions and interpolations and
interpolations okay that is one way in which we can conclude this
archeological next coming to the literary sources two
categories indigenous and foreign right first we are going to
deal with the indigenous sources indigenous sources can also be categorized into
religious and secular sour religious
sources religious sources can themselves be categorized into Hindu literature
with this literature and gen
lit first we are going to talk about Hindu literature now Hindu
literature may also be subdivided into two categories to the
literature also known as a
Oran and secondly R literature okay now shuti literature is considered
to be revealed sages and then they have translated
orally to younger generation this is how that literature has survived over several Generations before it was
written down for the first meaning to hear right these are revealed words a purushan right purush
means human being man right a purush mean somebody who is not so it is of nonhuman origin humans creation that
means it is of divine origin these are revealed Works which are considered to be of divine
origin literature only the four V can you name them chronological
order rade Sade yajur and
atar the VAS themselves consist of four different types of
wordss each V has a samita it can have one or more Brahman Associated to
it similarly it can have multiple arakas Associated and several
total 108 samita is the core text of the vas okay these are collections
of HS it is collection of mantras which must be recited in order to propitiate God in order to worship God dedicated to
different gods and God okay these are the original Vic Works
clear now next set of Vic Works to emerge were the brahmanas with the passage of time
the Vic religion became performative and became ritualized in so along with the chanting ofas certain sacrifices Yas be
per so certain to be created so these were codified in the
form of works as so these contain
details of rituals okay now as the religion became
more and more ritualized vly domination started to because rituals became the medium through which the priests allowed
certain people to participate fate and religious activity While disallowing others it became the basis for social
inequality also right now some people were in favor of it others were not in favor
and debate debate discussing the veracity or theity of these rituals this is going to result
in the creation of a new set ofure known as AR comes from the
word Forest so these are also known as Forest books written by philosophers who had taken s and gone into the
forest introspection discussions and on the basis of that they came to their
philosophical conclusions so these arakas contain philosophical debates about the rituals they try to
philosophically examine rituals some of them support some of the rituals while some rituals are condemned okay so these
are philosophical explanations of philosophical tradition religion
Associated and it is going to mature in the misss these are works of pure reason these are works of pure philosophy
dealing with the ideas of metaphysics they try to answer questions such as what is the nature of
God what is the nature of the universe that he has is it mutable or is it unchangeable is it permanent or is it
temporary it has been created can it be destroyed or is it permanent in what is the relationship between man and God
what is the life force of uh human beings Soul right what is the association of
Soul with the idea of death what happens after it life after death salvation Mo these were
the kinds of things that viic literature or shui okay now out of all this literature all
this Vic literature only the samita of the rig belongs to the
early from 1500 to 1,00 BC and later Vic from 1,00 to 600 so out of all this literature only
the RC samita belongs to the early VI the rest of the Vic literature belongs to
the the Vic literature was only composed during the V was compiled much later after their creation they were
transmitted orally for several Generations fact over thousands of years or at least hundreds of
years so they had been composed originally during the rig Vic age or the later Vic age but they were written down
compiled for the first time only during the post okay so the period of their composition and compilation is different
vas in the initial period were transmitted to the oral oral tradition is this
clear clear next we come to the SMY l
memory right so these are works that have been created by different philosophers that have been prepared by
different philosophers based upon their memory and their own understanding of the
first of all we have the
vangas right in operator manual inspection man V and the ritual Machinery associated
with it it is like a complex Machinery that needs to be operated in a specific manner in this operator manual these are
known as the vangas they are considered to be limbs of the V
they limbs of the vas total how many vangas six vas okay they are connected to the vas
but they're not part of six vangas
Sika that is phonetics kalpa which
covers ritual jotish which
covers astrology NTA which covers
atmology vakar which covers the grammar of the vas and
Chanda ch which deals with the meter or
Tempo vas and the rituals associated with it require that the mantas and the words of the vas must be pronounced
is the rituals associated with the with sorry with the huh with the brahmanas are to be performed with the specific
rituals me in specific conditions they have to be performed astrology becomes important
the meaning of the different words root to Source important mology or every V has its own grammar that is
distinct from the others that is important to learn and the Vic chanting has to be done in a specific manner with
specific timing Tempo unique that has to be learned so CH or right now among these
also consists of a category of literature known as Sutra
literature kalpa deals with which aspect of the Vic Faith with the ritualistic aspect or Sutra literature
is he ritualis ritualistic aspect or further elabor it consists
of R Sutra Ria Sutra and
dhas suas right sutras deal with elaborate rituals
very very complex rituals that were performed in a public setting only and only by Kings these are the rituals or
rituals these are performed by the ordinary householder within the confines of the household with or without the
presence of a priest dhas Sutra on the other hand deals with a completely
different sutras sought to modify andiz social interactions so the purpose of the Dharma sutras was
to impose certain sets of Rights duties and responsibilities upon different subjects or different parts of the
population so men duties duties upper duties lower duties right upper lower upper duties
obligations women are lower right so this was a meant or this was introduced in order
to uh introduce a new order within the societ okay so it sought to
codify the new social order
that had emerged since the later VI AG come to know that a transformation
the society went from being egalitarian and flat to being more and more stratified and unequal differences
between the rich and poor started increasing differences between the upper and lower ver started increasing women
condition soet became dominated more and more by men and obviously using the tool of religion
dhas purpose to reinforce the new social order that had emerged ever since the dater
V okay and these DH sutras were written by different sets of Scholars and that is why they are known by different names
for example goam sura a Sutra vist
Sutra bhan Sutra Vishnu Sutra Etc names of the different Scholars and
philosopher the priests who compiled these Dharma sutras is this clear
nowas they are part not only of Vang at the same time they are also part of a separate category of with literature
known as harash shastras okay so one line you can also add
sutras or ously considered to be part
of both the gangas
and D shastras is another category of literature category ofure
six Andra gtra and DH Sutra lit so second category of SMY
literature upas so upas are considered to be sub Vedas or minedas that are
associated with one of the vas Vas and they deal with a specific skill or
subject write down they are considered to be are considered to be adjuncts of the
vdas adjuncts of the vdas dealing
with specific subjects or skills specific subjects or skills a
deals with which subject
medicine and is associated with which V Riga second
gandhar deals with B subject which skill music associated
with which V musical v s then we have
the anur deals with with subject
D B and arrow arazi associated with
yajur and finally weapons it deals with Warfare
and weaponry this one is associated with the last V
okay two types of SMY literature we have covered vangas and upas
vangas four okay then we have number
three the harra
right subject matter what is the subject matter that they cover these are ancient Indian
law books they include the different
sutras as part of the uh kalpa literature right goam Sutra V Etc
right Hera as defined by VNA and
asham okay it deals with social relations it imposes several rights and duties upon different sections of the
population then in derived a category of literature that is known as the SMY literature legal experts and Scholars
jurists inas and they have come up with their own versions of law codes these are proper
codes of law which are legally uh you can say enforceable
regions these different La codes were observed with varying degrees of uh you can
say enforcement okay these include works such as the
Manus the Y
the parashar smti the goam smti
ETC okay these are
modified La books covering both civil
and criminal law since the bulk of them are and since all of them are derived from Dharma
sutras which are themselves designed to uphold the rules associated with Verna and asham the law
reflect are they going to be of a liberal and Democratic nature or a conservative and inequal nature
conservative and inequal nature and then we finally
have commentaries on thees themselves okay in the form
of nebun these are leny trees are written in the form of commentaries on thees for
example Cy SCH known as com known
as the laws mentioned by have been interpreted in a fresh Light in order to fix in the context of the early medieval
period in north rajo polities or societies modify nians these are ring
isas particular comment on a particular issue or context is a commentary right
so for example yal talks about let us say the rights of women when it comes to the inheritance
of ancestral property allow comment context women should be allowed
to inherit property what should be the virtues that a woman must displ in order to be able to inherit property what are
the conditions under which a woman would be ineligible to inherit ancestral property
and sras collections or
compilations the acted as legal manuals right so for example some legal justification would
have to be found for it so the legal Scholars are going to go through all the law books and
relevants comp to justify this new policy or argue why certain other policies are not
Suited these are the commentaries on the uh smritis
suasis and the commentaries they fall under the category of DH shastras these are ancient Indian
laws third category was the DH fourth category Bans
right what do you mean by the word puran ancient or old right so these at the time of their creation were
relatively recent and came after The Vedas various other smti works Etc but those people who are in charge of
creating them wanted to give the sense that these are ancient they are as old as time itself
why because these were not necessarily historical accounts or necessarily uh legal treatises they did not want to
deal directly with the human world rather they were devotional works right now
purans began emerging during the post Moran period
but the bulk of them were compiled during the
Gupta that is 2 Century
wec to maybe the 6th century 6th Century ad time period of
compilation what is the nature of these works at this point of time major changes were
taking Trend emerge which was a protest movement against brahmanical domination as well as Buddhism what was that
bi okay essence of devotion right so these were devotional
texts dedicated to different gods and goddesses They Carried the legends
of different gods and
goddesses okay now there are a total
of 18 major puranas or mahapuran
and numerous urans or minor purans now five important features of
purans are very important to appreciate if we want to understand the real nature of this
L these include SGA
pra anantra one van or
VSA and Van shanu charu right
s consists of the creation mythological Tales each of them tries to explain the
process of Creation in their own way myology develop another element
istis so according to the purans creation of universe is it a natural phenomena or a
Divine Divine phenomen Supernatural God okay most places Brahma is the creator right according to the puran
writers the universe is not permanent it is temporary right God has created it and God is going to destroy it also
but multiple once destroyed it will be created a new and it is it is going to
go on through its own lifestyle and then be destroyed again this is going to be an endless side okay so mids of
Destruction and Recreation were elaborated in the prara feature
portion then mananta this was the most important uh feature
to tell us about the Quran writers conception of time
that every cycle between destruction and Recreation or between the creation of the universe and destruction of the
universe consists of sorry 14 manav anas
right manav means or manu right or antra means period right so 14 ages of so that means 14 ages uh in which the cycle of
time repeats itself and each of these 14 man Manas consist of
four yugas and
right before the universe is destroyed then recreated right conception of time a combination
of the linear as well as cyclical flow of ages of
Manu and the conception of time is elaborated in
this then we have buch right this talks about the
geneology of different gods and godess
says which God is the child of which other God which God is the relative of which other God lineage dynast different
gods and goddesses belong right God goddesses and sages
okay and finally we have one shanu what are these these were
the dynastic records of Kings okay now one interesting thing which
took place was the blending of history with mythology Kings historical
records deliberately mer with the V of gods goddesses Andes for example that the tribe was
descended from the sage vishwam right so that is one m and similarly uh guptas they claim to be descendants of the uh
suryan that is associated with Lord Ram ikaku dynasty of the Andra region 13th sorry thir 11th century r that also
claimed to be a descendant of the ikaku dynasty of Lord Ram SU rulers then Raj Kings chra
and div this is how the dynastic records are related and historical
records myologic record this is a bid to gain legitimacy in which the Priestly class which is the
custodian of this literature and the royal class which seeks to gain the most they enter into an into an alliance a
coalition okay now the Quran literature apart from these features also sheds light on the
cultural context in which it was written for example langage langage socials
[Music] cities descri Rivers
Valle aess technology that also belong to theod
thator around proliferation or maybe they are talking about the use of iron aot tips also
right specifically these kinds of things we can get to know from the qurans then
there is another set of literature associated with the SMY literature known
as ithas literature yeah IAS literature the
epics the great epics of India the Mahabharat
and ramayan now the
epics and the purans together form what is known as the
IAS Quan tradition right Quan tradition that we are going
to discuss in tomorrow's class task before coming to the class tomorrow and go through the previous
years questions Associated withes come to me and I will clarify okay all right Nores that goes
for you too here all right so if there are no doubts I'll be ending this session right now
[Music]
Archaeological sources include physical remains such as mounds from settlements or graves, artifacts like ornaments and tools, inscriptions on durable materials, organic remnants such as fossilized bones, structures including temples and palaces, paintings like cave art, and dwellings such as caves and rock shelters. These remains provide tangible evidence about past societies.
Horizontal excavation covers large areas quickly and is cost-effective but may struggle with sites that are still inhabited. Vertical excavation digs deeper into layers, providing detailed stratigraphic information about chronological sequences, though it is more time-consuming and expensive. Archaeologists choose methods based on the research goals and site conditions.
Archaeological evidence offers primary, contemporary insights into economic systems, social structures, and technology, especially valuable for periods without written records like the Stone Age. However, it can be incomplete due to decay of organic materials, disturbance of artifacts, and lacks narrative context such as language and social norms, necessitating careful interpretation.
Literary sources include indigenous religious texts (like the Vedas and Dharma Shastras), secular works (epics, scientific treatises), and foreign traveler accounts. They provide rich cultural and philosophical context but can contain biases or interpolations, so historians corroborate them with archaeological data to build accurate historical narratives.
Numismatics analyzes coins to reveal economic conditions, technological progress, religious practices, and political timelines, noting transitions such as from punch-marked to standardized coins under Indo-Greek influence. Epigraphy studies inscriptions that document royal decrees, social customs, and administrative details; these records, like Ashoka's edicts, are considered reliable and less susceptible to manipulation than literary texts.
Integrating both sources allows historians to create a fuller and nuanced picture of India's past. Archaeology supplies concrete physical evidence crucial for periods lacking texts, while literary sources enrich understanding of social values, beliefs, and narratives. Cross-verification helps overcome the limitations inherent in either source alone, leading to more accurate historical reconstructions.
Further insights can be gained by exploring resources like the "Comprehensive Overview of Ancient Indian History: From Prehistoric to Gupta Empire," which offers an extensive timeline complementing archaeological and literary data. Additionally, studies on the "Early Vedic Age" provide cultural context, and guides on "Prehistoric Archaeology and Dating Methods" offer explanations of archaeological techniques and challenges.
Heads up!
This summary and transcript were automatically generated using AI with the Free YouTube Transcript Summary Tool by LunaNotes.
Generate a summary for freeRelated Summaries
The Itihas-Puran Tradition and Foreign Travelogues in Ancient Indian History
This summary explores the Itihas-Puran tradition, a unique blend of mythology and history that shaped ancient Indian historical consciousness, alongside critical evaluations of literary sources and foreign travelogues. It highlights their origins, features, strengths, and limitations in reconstructing India's past, emphasizing their continued influence on modern Indian culture.
Comprehensive Overview of Ancient Indian History: From Prehistoric to Gupta Empire
This video provides an in-depth exploration of Ancient Indian History, covering significant periods from the Prehistoric era through the Gupta Empire. Key topics include the Indus Valley Civilization, Vedic Period, rise of Jainism and Buddhism, and the political dynamics of the Maurya and Gupta empires.
Understanding the Prehistoric Period of India: A Comprehensive Overview
This summary explores the prehistoric period of India, detailing the evolution of human life from the Stone Age to the Chalcolithic phase. It highlights key archaeological findings, cultural developments, and the transition from prehistoric to historic times.
A Comprehensive History of India: From Ancient Civilizations to Independence
Explore the rich history of India, from its earliest human activity and ancient civilizations like the Harappan and Vedic Aryans, through the rise and fall of empires such as the Mauryan, Gupta, and Mughal, to the struggle for independence led by Mahatma Gandhi. This summary highlights key cultural, religious, and political milestones that shaped India’s legacy.
Early Vedic Age: An Overview of Aryan Migration and Civilization
This summary explores the Early Vedic Age, marking the arrival of the Aryans in India around 1500 BC, leading to the development of Vedic civilization. It discusses the key texts, cultural features, political structure, social life, and economic aspects of the period, highlighting its significance in Indian history.
Most Viewed Summaries
Kolonyalismo at Imperyalismo: Ang Kasaysayan ng Pagsakop sa Pilipinas
Tuklasin ang kasaysayan ng kolonyalismo at imperyalismo sa Pilipinas sa pamamagitan ni Ferdinand Magellan.
A Comprehensive Guide to Using Stable Diffusion Forge UI
Explore the Stable Diffusion Forge UI, customizable settings, models, and more to enhance your image generation experience.
Pamamaraan at Patakarang Kolonyal ng mga Espanyol sa Pilipinas
Tuklasin ang mga pamamaraan at patakaran ng mga Espanyol sa Pilipinas, at ang epekto nito sa mga Pilipino.
Mastering Inpainting with Stable Diffusion: Fix Mistakes and Enhance Your Images
Learn to fix mistakes and enhance images with Stable Diffusion's inpainting features effectively.
Pamaraan at Patakarang Kolonyal ng mga Espanyol sa Pilipinas
Tuklasin ang mga pamamaraan at patakarang kolonyal ng mga Espanyol sa Pilipinas at ang mga epekto nito sa mga Pilipino.

