Low Credibility
0 verified, 0 misleading, 0 false, 0 unverifiable out of 0 claims analyzed
The video transcript presents a highly opinionated commentary by a host who praises a former PS deputy, Arcēncio Simões, for critiquing left-wing politics and justifying police action during protests. The host makes several factual claims, about tourism growth (69% from 2015-2025), an increase of 1.2 million immigrants, foreign real estate investment share rising from 5% to 28%, and specific details about European far-left groups and protest tactics in Barcelona (23 shopping centers invaded, 34 fires, 128 arrests, 78 minors). However, the transcript lacks citations, timestamps, and verifiable sources for these statistics and claims. The overall credibility is low due to the uncritical presentation of sweeping assertions without evidence, reliance on a single politically charged source, and the absence of fact-checking or counterpoints. The video appears to be a partisan commentary rather than a balanced fact-based analysis.
Hello friends. Welcome back. I hope you are well, friends. I don't know if you know—you surely know—the expression
"my soul is stunned." This expression fits like a glove in this case, because we usually have a video on Tuesday that
almost every week ends up highlighting something Miguel Morgado said the day before, and the day before is Monday
night. But Miguel Morgado says very interesting things. However, this video isn't about Miguel Morgado, because
this video could have been about this man's intervention, it could have been about Miguel Morgado's intervention,
but it is an intervention from someone we didn't expect to have this intervention, because this person is
someone who was once a deputy for the PS, the Portuguese Socialist Party, but , thank God, he manages to be someone
who at least spoke a lot of truth. Everything he said about the left itself was incredible. Listening to him
, I changed a bit the way I often evaluate certain people on the left, because we can often find light even in
the darkest of places. And in this case , Simões is proof of exactly that. Being a man of the left, having even
been a deputy for the Socialist Party, where were all these people on the left during the almost 10 years of Socialist
Party governments and even the Geringonça? Just the following, to provide data. Between 2015 and 2025,
the number of tourists increased by 69% . This is a fact. The number of immigrants, that is, people who came to
Portugal, increased by 1.2 million people. It is a fact. The share of foreign investors in real estate went
from 5%in 2015 to 28%in 2025. This happened under left-wing governments. So why have all these people on the
left only now discovered that they are on the left? I have been watching this for two and a half years.
>> But regarding the position of silence, silence is also a position. >> Where are or where were the people when
the left governed for so long? Incredible. This could have been said by anyone from the center-right, but it
was someone from the left. Because, friends, it is good to have people who also have this ability to unmask their
own political spectrum. And this is incredible. And I really liked hearing this gentleman who spoke so much truth;
he deserves praise, but he didn't stop there. He continued. >> You know that when police forces
intervene, they have two things: their own information and the information from the intelligence community. It's
not like a commissioner is there at the protest giving an order to start beating people, no. Democratic security
forces in a democratic country have access to information and public entities are also informed of the
intelligence that >> in your opinion, was the police action appropriate.
>> I would like to draw your attention to the following. We have many groups of the so-called far-left in Europe today.
I think even the journalist is a bit stunned by these statements. She seems almost uncomfortable. And so, if this
is being watched by her bosses at the newsroom or even at home, man, they aren't always working, right? They
start thinking, man, it wasn't enough to have Miguel Margado's uncomfortable truths, now we also have a leftist
saying practically the same thing Miguel Margado says. I think we're screwed.
>> These groups are formed by anarchists and Trotskyists. Many revolutionary people whose main goal is to fight
against capitalism and against bourgeois democracy. In France we have the Movimira, in Albania we have the
Flamingo movement, in Italy we have the October 17th movement, and in Spain we have the Barcelona blocs. Do you know
what we have in Portugal? Behind these protests, we have something called United Workers. This United Workers is
a split from the Socialist Alternative movement of Gil Garcia, which was already a split from the Left Bloc. In
a way, he is legitimizing the police intervention, but he did something even more incredible from our point of view,
which was to list the numerous extremist leftist groups that create and have been creating chaos in Europe.
And >> these United Workers have two coordinators in these protests, one in
Porto and another in Lisbon. In Lisbon, it's a woman named Renata Cambra, and in Porto, it's a man named João
Silvestre. Any journalists who want to can track who these two people are over time. They are two leaders of the
United Workers, a movement that brings together anarchists, Trotskyists, the far-left, revolutionaries against
capitalism and bourgeois democracy, and they all share the same easy way of working.
>> Do you really think journalism would be interested in covering this, in us uncovering this? In the view of the
Portuguese, this makes perfect sense, but I doubt this will be done. Truly the things we learned from Miguel
Margado, that we learned from Anécio, Ancêncio Simões, very good >> which was what happened in France, what
happened in Italy, what happened in Albania, and what also happened in Barcelona this weekend, which is they
choose a problem that makes sense. Then they gather in small groups of friends, provoke the authorities, the
authorities react, taking that provocation into account, and they secure broader support from people who
think that social complaint makes sense . >> Then he explains, as many have already
explained in the past, and we here at the Abraço da Verdade channel have also done so, how these movements work.
I am amazed. >> But do you think there was provocation here in the Portuguese context? We are
naturally talking about the context in Barcelona. There was provocation right away in Porto, and we already commented
on that last week, >> right? >> The provocation is constant. The
provocation is constant and it is documented. Because that right there is the problem. Right from the start,
there is the provocation of staying past the scheduled time. Then there is the provocation of setting up an
illegal camp, and then the provocation against the police that occurred at various moments. And then there is the
constitution of revolutionary bases. What are these agents doing? What are these coordinating groups doing?
Registering naive people. Who believe in the cause and are there for the cause itself. Then there is a moment
where there is an ignition. The ignition caused the riots. It happened in France, it happened in Albania, it
happened in Italy, and it happened this weekend in Barcelona. I think that >> the journalist here realizes that it's
not even worth going against what he says, because what he is saying is the pure truth and the truth in this case
is on this man's side, but this man finishes on a high note. Pay close attention. The government—and it
happened in Albania, which is a socialist government, and it happened in Barcelona, which is a socialist
government—and in Barcelona, something simple happened. The socialist government limited police
action for several weeks until the day when it was no longer possible to hold out, and then they were playing
catch-up. There were 23 shopping centers invaded by the riot and there were 34 fires. 128 people were arrested
, 78 of whom were minors. This is the modus operandi of these groups, the far-left groups that are operating
today in democracies and then take advantage of people who fight against democracy, who want the greatest of
freedoms. But what they want is not to defend democracy; it is to attack our democracy and it is to attack our
freedom, because they think that capitalism and pluralist democracy are things, are things that shouldn't exist
. Friends, the reality that many want to hide, this man said it all, he said it all. And this is music to our ears,
that we have someone who calls themselves left-wing, able above all to understand what is happening, able to
make an assessment of what has been done. And what has been done was simply to destroy our country and then look at
the people who are protesting and realize where these people were when the most important decisions for our
country and the decisions that most harmed our country were made. Where were those people? This is a person on
the left. This is a person on the left saying this. That is why what this gentleman said is so important, that I
have already tried to say his name two or three times and I ask you to forgive me, Mr. Arcêncio Simões, the doctor
or I don't know, he probably has a doctorate in something. So, this socialist manages to be an example of
someone, as I said, he is a light in the middle of so much...no, he is a light in the middle of the darkness,
where so many people are there to try to cover things up, to try to make people not remember the past, so that
people have difficulty interpreting what is happening. This gentleman sits down, practically taking Miguel
Morgado's place in unraveling the truth , in not having trouble saying what is going on, in making an assessment of
the past and, above all, also managing to demonstrate that if Portugal does nothing, this will reach here. So, very
well done, Mr. Ascêncio Simões. Very well, very well. I really enjoyed listening. Thank you, friends. I would
really like to hear your opinion. Thank you for being on that side. Thank you for agreeing with my words and stay in
peace. See you in the next video.
O vídeo apresenta baixa credibilidade porque faz afirmações estatísticas ousadas (como aumento de 69% no turismo e de 1,2 milhão de imigrantes) sem citar fontes verificáveis, timestamps ou estudos oficiais. Além disso, é um comentário partidário que não oferece contrapontos ou checagem de fatos.
O vídeo não fornece fontes específicas ou links para esses dados estatísticos. Para verificar tais alegações, seria necessário consultar órgãos oficiais como o Instituto Nacional de Estatística (INE) ou relatórios do Banco de Portugal, que não foram mencionados no conteúdo analisado.
Esses números detalhados sobre ações de grupos de extrema-esquerda na Europa não possuem verificação independente no vídeo. Sem citações de relatórios policiais, notícias ou fontes governamentais, essas estatísticas devem ser tratadas com ceticismo até confirmação cruzada.
Não. O conteúdo é um comentário unidirecional que elogia uma figura política de direita e critica a esquerda sem apresentar evidências contrárias ou entrevistas com outros especialistas. Isso reduz significativamente sua credibilidade como análise objetiva.
Recomenda-se buscar dados em fontes oficiais como o Eurostat (para imigração na UE), a Organização Mundial do Turismo (OMT) e o Serviço de Estrangeiros e Fronteiras (SEF) de Portugal. Compare os números do vídeo com os relatórios anuais dessas instituições públicas.
Sim, pois o ex-deputado é uma figura política com viés partidário claro. Citar apenas uma fonte politicamente engajada sem contextualizar seu posicionamento compromete a neutralidade e a verificabilidade das informações apresentadas.
Sempre busque: 1) Verificar se números e datas têm fontes citadas, 2) Procurar reportagens independentes sobre os mesmos eventos, 3) Conferir a reputação do canal/apresentador, e 4) Usar ferramentas de checagem como o Observador ou FactCheck.pt para confrontar estatísticas.
Keep this fact check
Save it to LunaNotes and it becomes a real note in your library — editable, searchable, and ready to turn into flashcards or a diagram. Free to start.
Save to LunaNotesOr fact check for another video.
32K+ people have turned 65K+ videos into notes
“Very useful tool. I'm using it for the last couple weeks and I'm loving it so far. Makes learning on YouTube a great experience.”
This fact check was automatically generated using AI with the Free YouTube video fact checker by LunaNotes. Sources are AI-generated and should be independently verified.
Related fact checks
Fact Check: Gabriel Attal on RTL – Riots, Authority, and EU Elections Claims Analyzed
This analysis fact-checks Gabriel Attal's RTL interview where he discussed the 2025 riots, calling for a state of emergency and criticizing government failures. Several claims are verified but lack specific data, while his assertion about a legal social media shutdown is factually accurate but context-dependent.
Fact Check: Dan Woodton on Tommy Robinson Trial, London Chaos, and Douglas Murray Claims
Analysis of Dan Woodton's Outspoken episode reveals mixed credibility with several misleading claims about Oxford Street pedestrianization and exaggerated rhetoric about civil war. The segment on Tommy Robinson's trial is constrained by contempt laws but overall score reflects unverified assertions about migrant policies and political figures.
Fact Check: Did Immigrants Cause Paris to Burn? Analyzing Viral Riots Claims
This fact-check analyzes a video claiming that Paris and other French cities have been destroyed by uncontrolled third-world immigration, with scenes of burning government buildings and looting that are described as worse than World War II. Our investigation found that the video presents a highly misleading narrative, often mixing genuine protest footage from different years and events with exaggerated and unsubstantiated claims about immigrants and political actors. Several key assertions are false or taken out of context, leading to a low credibility score.
Fact Check: French Streamer Debunks Neoliberalism & Leftist Economics
This fact-check analyzes a French streamer's claims about neoliberalism, price signals, French inequality, and global poverty. The speaker makes several misleading or false assertions, including denying the validity of the term 'neoliberalism' and misrepresenting the ratio of French income inequality. Overall credibility is rated as mixed, with some verified points but significant factual distortions.
Fact Check: Éric Ciotti’s Claim of LFI-Linked Violence and ‘Two Frances’ in 2027
A fact-check of Éric Ciotti’s speech reveals multiple unsubstantiated claims, including the characterization of unrest as a 'dress rehearsal' orchestrated by Jean-Luc Mélenchon and La France Insoumise, and the framing of a 'clash of two Frances' by 2027. The analysis finds a lack of evidence for systemic LFI involvement, misleading historical analogies, and significant factual errors regarding the abolished 'anti-rioter law' and juvenile justice system.
Most viewed fact checks
Fact Check: April 2026 Regulus-Sphinx Alignment and Biblical Prophecy
This fact-check examines the claim that the star Regulus will align with the Sphinx's gaze at Easter 2026, signalling a significant spiritual or prophetic event as proposed by Chris Bledso. We evaluate the astronomical accuracy of the claimed alignment, the biblical connections, and warnings about deception in prophecy.
Fact Check: April 2026 Rapture Predictions and Related Claims
This video makes multiple prophetic and biblical claims prophesying an imminent rapture event around April 4th to 5th, 2026, linking various visions, interpretations, and speculative timelines. Our fact-check finds that these claims are unsupported by credible evidence or mainstream religious scholarship and involve unverifiable personal revelations and misinterpretations of historical and biblical texts.
Fact Check: Claims About Noah's Ark Discovery on Turkey's Highest Peak
This fact-check examines the sensational claims of an alleged Noah's Ark discovery on a Turkish mountain peak, analyzing the archaeological, scientific, and biblical assertions made. Our investigation finds no credible evidence supporting the extraordinary details presented, many of which contradict established science and historical knowledge.
Fact Check: Zoink's Record Breaks and Impossible Levels in Geometry Dash
This fact check analyzes the claims about Geometry Dash player Zoink's achievements, including his record completions of notoriously difficult levels such as Booambama, Exasperation, and Silent Circles. While most accomplishments verify with community data and documented runs, some details on attempts and timelines require cautious interpretation.
Fact Check: Prophetic Claims and the Essene Calendar Explained
This video presents claims about the prophetic significance of the Essene calendar, its connection to biblical prophecy, and recent historical events. While some historical facts about the Dead Sea Scrolls and Jewish history are accurate, the prophetic interpretations and calendar correlations remain speculative and unverified by mainstream scholarship.
Found this fact check useful?
Take it with you. One click puts it in your own LunaNotes library.
Save to LunaNotes