Overview of IGCSE Global Perspectives Question 4
Question 4 assesses your ability to evaluate a government action addressing hunger among people living in poverty. You must select and justify one solution from provided options and support your stance using evidence from given source materials.
Understanding the Question
- Scenario: The government aims to reduce hunger for people in poverty.
- Options to choose from:
- Provide free food in poverty-stricken areas
- Invest in new farming technologies
- Train people to grow and sell food locally
Your task is to recommend one action and justify your choice thoroughly.
Recommended Answer Structure
To score full 20 marks, organize your response into clear paragraphs following this framework:
1. Recommendation
- State clearly which option you recommend.
- Use a formal paragraph format.
2. Advantages and Disadvantage of Your Choice
- Present at least two advantages of your chosen solution.
- Support points with citations from the source materials.
- Include at least one possible disadvantage or counterargument.
3. Analysis of Other Options
- Discuss the advantages and at least one disadvantage of the other two options.
- This showcases your understanding of alternative perspectives.
4. Significance of Your Choice
- Explain why your selected option is the most significant.
- Reference scale and impact: local, national, global, or cultural effects.
- Consider the influence on individuals, groups, and potential conflicts.
5. Acceptability and Implementation
- Outline how your recommended action can be implemented step-by-step.
- Discuss potential conflicts or barriers to acceptance.
- Address the cost and time frame for realization.
6. Conclusion
- Summarize why the advantages outweigh disadvantages.
- Reaffirm why your choice is the best solution based on evidence.
Key Tips for Success
- Use Evidence: Always cite relevant points from Source 1 to Source 4 to strengthen arguments.
- Incorporate Own Ideas: Blend source information with your critical analysis.
- Address Counterarguments: Demonstrates depth of evaluation.
- Focus on Impact: Discuss consequences and benefits in detail.
- Manage Time: Be clear and concise to cover all required parts.
For further strategies on organizing effective exam responses, see Mastering Evaluation for IB English Paper One.
Example Extract from a Model Answer
"To reduce hunger for people living in poverty, I recommend training people to grow and sell food locally. This option promotes sustainability by building long-term skills (Source 2) and fosters local economic growth. However, it may require time and resources to implement successfully. Compared to free food provision, this addresses root causes rather than just symptoms, making it a more impactful solution overall."
For additional insights on sustainability and evaluating cost-effective solutions, you may find the Comprehensive Guide to CIE IGCSE Biology: Key Concepts and Study Tips helpful, especially on analyzing long-term impacts.
Conclusion
By following this structured approach and integrating source-based evidence alongside your own insights, you can effectively evaluate the costs and benefits of government actions to reduce hunger, resulting in a focused, well-supported answer poised for top marks in IGCSE Global Perspectives Question 4.
um this is igcs Global Perspective um so quickly we're going to have a quick run through on how you can answer the uh
question four um that have to do with evaluation of cost of action this is a 20 mark
question so quickly this is how question four comes out um in this case they said the government want to reduce hunger for
people living in poverty and the following actions so you see we're looking at cost of actions which are
more like proposed solution to an issue are being considered and one of it is to provide free food in areas of poverty
now invest in new farming Technologies and train people to grow and sell food in the local area now you just have to
choose one of these options so um any of the option you choose is correct depending on how you could um explain it
in detail to get get the full 20 marks so there are certain criterias we're going to look at that if you do you
definitely get 20 marks now there say which one of these actions uh would you recommend to the government and why so
that's that's that's the basic thing why will you choose any of these C of action so that's what we're looking
at um now this is this question is based on um you definitely need to get evidence from your sources so you look
at from Source One to Source Four can be used in um this particular question now there's this is this is the criteria
here so IED tell my student that you just need to know how to analyze this content here to get your 20 marks now
they said in your answer you should State your recommendation so this is more like in paragraph format try to
make sure your work is properly presented now your first parag gra should be your recommendation should be
your recommendation so you should should be your recommendation sorry so in your recommendation you
should just select one of these options that's all so you're done with this now here we begin to enter the tricky part
where they say you should give reasons and evidence to support your choice now here is is quite simple so your second
paragraph should follow up with you should Now give me the advantages should give me the
advantages of your choice or of your option now you should give me at least you we should be looking at two
advantages of your choice and you should give me at least one possible one possible disadvantage of your
choice now this will make sure that you're looking at um counter argument that's that's
it now after you've done that the if you look at this now they said you should consider
different argument and perspective and you should always use the source material
and your own idea so as you're stating the advantages and disadvantages always use what source
materials so the source materials we talking about here should be possibly you you able to pick an advantage from
Source One so you should be able to State it you should be able to state if you got an advantage from Source two you
should be able to state if you get from Source three disadvantage whichever so make sure you make reference to the
sources as you explain the content for your answer now the third major paragraph we look at is you should also
look at the other choices so looking at the other choices help you to develop different perspectives so if you pick
this as your first you should also look at this and this so you look at the other uh and choices that you did not
pick so you look at the other choices now when looking at the other choices what you should do is you look at the
advantage and also the disadvantage if you can and if possible because you know this is time you should be time
conscious if you can give one advantage and possibly two
disadvantage of these other two choices now that should make up possibly your third and fourth paragraph if you can
combine them using collectives in your third paragraph to that
okay then immediately after that you need to now remember you want to recommend your choice and you want to
convince whoever you're given this course of action to choose it so your fourth paragraph you should look at why
your choice is the most significant why your choice is the most significant
Miss significant after that if you if you don't know how to explain the most
significant please you can check um how to answer question number one I think is there I explained that earlier so the
fifth paragraph you should now talk about the acceptability
acceptability of your choice so here you should tell us how it can be implemented possibly step by-step guide
of how it can be implemented so here you can talk about um some potential
conflict that can result from you or from you uh implementing your choice and here you should also try to talk about
the cost of implementation so and also you should try to talk about time if it to take a
long time or short time now this structure is quite I've found out that over time is quite difficult
for some student to structure their work in this format but it's really really quite easy this is all you need to do
now see a format have been able to arrange it in this format uh using for the 20 marks so the first paragraph is
your recommendation so my recommendation is you state it to justify I will now so that's how you should start it then the
second paragraph is that you tell us the positive impact of your choice you can tell us how it impacts the environment
uh you should always include citation from the insert and you should also give us one potential uh uh uh counter
argument that can result from from your choice so you can look at the way I structure the second paragraph the third
one you look at the other options the fourth one you look at the second other option you give your reasons the
advantages and disadvantages of the two options then you now tell us how significant your choice is now the
significance of your choice is that it affect the greatest number of people locally nationally globally and
culturally then you should be able to tell us how it affect people within that Dimension that will also introduce the
concept of different perspective now you tell us your choice why will it be accepted that in the acceptability and
implementation there you talk about time you talk about cost you can talk about um possible potential conflict you
should talk about people that also might be involved in the implementation process now once you
do that you conclude you talk about how your advantages overlap your disadvantages and why your choice is
better that's all that is all now always always remember always use evidence from the
insert and your own idea very important anytime you do not use evidence or your own idea it means the third criteria
here have not been accomplished and what is it use material from sources and any of your own idea so you should do
that now this is a sample candidate answer to to to to to for the 20 mark question he said said to reduce hunger
for people living in poverty I would advise the government to train people to grow and sell food in local areas now
that is their option now training people provide long term that's time um blah blah blah blah blah it is
sustainable training gives the skill that so here they trying to explain why it is the most significant why their
option is the best so that is what this question is all about now this action has the most impact so
if you look at the second paragraph here they've moved to most impact so most significant here they've spoken about
advantages disadvantages of their choice now when you move you see here they've moved to talking about the other choices
these are the other two choices the advantages and disadvantages of the other two choices been explained now if
you read through you see here they've mentioned Source two so they mentioned they use different sources and they use
examples from their own idea on how uh uh they can profile solution or a cuse of action to a particular problem now
that is it now look at the content that the examiner have in the max scheme to assess your work now reference to scale
of impact so when explaining scale of impact remember this scale of impact you
talk about it at in your most significant aspect So when you say most significant
is the most significant the greatest impact it affect most people it create a vicious cycle it has a lot of
consequences so reference to different consequences you still talk about that in your most
significant now how long it takes so this should be under uh implementation acceptability of your choice barrier to
change this should be under potential conflict potential conflict so people that might
go against the implementation the influence on individual and group in making decisions so that should be under
most significant when you talk about it affect people locally nationally globally the role of vested interest and
power differences that should also be on most significant so that's it then potential conflict of Interest so that
should be under why it is most significant because mention potential conflict there difficulty in planning
this should be under your implementation and cost okay we mentioned that also and resource so once you explain it in this
aspect you get your full Mark always always remember to include your what source evidence Source from the inser
from Source One to sour five thank you
Question 4 requires students to evaluate a government action aimed at reducing hunger among people living in poverty by selecting one proposed solution, justifying their choice with evidence from source materials, and analyzing alternatives to demonstrate critical thinking and balanced evaluation.
Organize your response into six clear paragraphs: 1) State your recommended solution; 2) Discuss advantages and a disadvantage of your choice with source evidence; 3) Analyze advantages and a disadvantage of other options; 4) Explain the significance and impact of your chosen solution; 5) Describe implementation steps, potential conflicts, costs, and timelines; 6) Conclude by summarizing why your choice is best based on evidence.
Incorporate direct references and citations from the provided source materials to support your advantages, disadvantages, and analysis. Combining this evidence with your own critical evaluation strengthens your argument and demonstrates depth of understanding.
Focus on citing relevant sources, blending source information with your own ideas, addressing counterarguments to show balanced evaluation, discussing impacts in detail, and managing your time to ensure each section is clear and concise for comprehensive coverage.
Discussing advantages and disadvantages of the alternatives shows your ability to consider multiple perspectives, enhancing the quality of your evaluation and proving a well-rounded understanding, which is crucial for high marks.
Outline practical steps for putting your recommended solution into action, identify potential conflicts or acceptance barriers, and discuss associated costs and timeframes. This demonstrates realistic and critical thinking about how your choice would work in real life.
An example highlighted is recommending training people to grow and sell food locally, emphasizing sustainability and economic growth supported by source evidence, acknowledging challenges like implementation time and resources, and contrasting it with less effective options such as only providing free food.
Heads up!
This summary and transcript were automatically generated using AI with the Free YouTube Transcript Summary Tool by LunaNotes.
Generate a summary for freeRelated Summaries
Comprehensive Guide to Food Nutrition: Health, Culture, Sustainability, and Innovation
Explore the multifaceted world of food nutrition, from its vital role in personal health and cultural identity to global challenges in sustainable production and food accessibility. This guide also delves into modern dietary trends, government policies, and cutting-edge food technologies shaping the future of our food systems.
Addressing Child Poverty and Inequality in Australia: Key Insights from a Keynote Presentation
In this keynote presentation, the speaker emphasizes the urgent need for policymakers to listen to and act on the voices of children and young people, particularly those from marginalized backgrounds. The discussion highlights the interconnectedness of child poverty, inequality, and the importance of adequate support systems in fostering the development of all young Australians.
Understanding Social Stratification for AQA GCSE Sociology
This video provides a comprehensive overview of social stratification, focusing on functionalist, Marxist, and feminist perspectives. It covers key concepts such as socioeconomic class, life chances, poverty, and power dynamics, essential for AQA GCSE Sociology students preparing for their exams.
Comprehensive Guide to Crop Care and Maintenance for Grade 7
Explore essential crop care and harvesting practices for grade 7 technology and livelihood education.
Mastering Evaluation for IB English Paper One
In this video, Andrew and Dave discuss the critical skill of evaluation for IB English Paper One, emphasizing its importance in achieving higher marks. They explore how to effectively use evaluative language, including verbs, adjectives, and adverbs, to enhance analysis and critical judgment in writing.
Most Viewed Summaries
Kolonyalismo at Imperyalismo: Ang Kasaysayan ng Pagsakop sa Pilipinas
Tuklasin ang kasaysayan ng kolonyalismo at imperyalismo sa Pilipinas sa pamamagitan ni Ferdinand Magellan.
A Comprehensive Guide to Using Stable Diffusion Forge UI
Explore the Stable Diffusion Forge UI, customizable settings, models, and more to enhance your image generation experience.
Mastering Inpainting with Stable Diffusion: Fix Mistakes and Enhance Your Images
Learn to fix mistakes and enhance images with Stable Diffusion's inpainting features effectively.
Pamamaraan at Patakarang Kolonyal ng mga Espanyol sa Pilipinas
Tuklasin ang mga pamamaraan at patakaran ng mga Espanyol sa Pilipinas, at ang epekto nito sa mga Pilipino.
Pamaraan at Patakarang Kolonyal ng mga Espanyol sa Pilipinas
Tuklasin ang mga pamamaraan at patakarang kolonyal ng mga Espanyol sa Pilipinas at ang mga epekto nito sa mga Pilipino.

